After a challenging 2024 season at first base, the New York Yankees are poised to reshape their infield. With Anthony Rizzo’s $17 million club option for 2025 declined, the Yankees must look for reliable options to strengthen their lineup. While top names like Pete Alonso might tempt some, General Manager Brian Cashman could be wiser to pursue more balanced or budget-friendly choices. Three potential fits at varying price points include Paul Goldschmidt, Carlos Santana, and Christian Walker.

Paul Goldschmidt: Veteran Experience at a Bargain

The Yankees could take a low-risk chance on Paul Goldschmidt, the former MVP who hit 22 home runs with a 100 wRC+ for the St. Louis Cardinals in 2024. Despite being 36, Goldschmidt’s road splits, featuring a 113 wRC+ and .182 ISO, suggest Yankee Stadium’s short right-field porch could revitalize his numbers. Statcast metrics, including a .429 xwOBACON, underline that Goldschmidt still possesses solid offensive traits. His current defensive abilities are serviceable, making him a feasible platoon option with Ben Rice. Should he command less than $10 million, the Yankees could add a seasoned hitter capable of steadying their lineup.

Carlos Santana: Switch-Hitting Leadership

At 39, Carlos Santana remains a valuable option due to his blend of power, discipline, and defensive acumen. In 2024, Santana posted a 114 wRC+ and smashed 23 home runs, bolstered by +11 Fielding Run Value. His compatibility with Yankee Stadium’s dimensions is clear, as he’d likely add a few more homers in the Bronx. Santana’s strong clubhouse presence is a bonus; known for inspiring teammates, he could bring leadership to a team in need of a veteran spark. With a probable one-year, cost-effective deal, Santana could contribute offensively while offering the Yankees flexibility at first base.

Christian Walker: The High-Impact Option

If the Yankees aim higher, Christian Walker stands out. Ranked fifth in fWAR (10.8) among first basemen since 2022 and leading in Fielding Run Value, Walker combines elite power with defensive reliability. He belted 26 home runs in 130 games in 2024, backed by a .428 xwOBACON and 13.3% Barrel Rate. Despite missing games due to injury, Walker’s potential to hit 30+ home runs consistently makes him a prime candidate for a multi-year deal similar to Jose Abreu’s three-year, $58.5 million contract. His addition would secure a formidable middle-of-the-order presence alongside Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton.

Each of these players offers unique strengths for the Yankees’ lineup. Whether prioritizing cost-effective experience or power-packed performance, New York’s first base conundrum could be solved with one strategic signing.